| Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
Athena College was snoozing
complacently in the Berkshires until Coleman Silk--formerly "Silky Silk,"
undefeated welterweight pro boxer--strode in and shook the place awake. This
faculty dean sacked the deadwood, made lots of hot new hires, including
Yale-spawned literary-theory wunderkind Delphine Roux, and pissed off so
many people for so many decades that now, in 1998, they've all turned on
him. Silk's character assassination is partly owing to what the novel's
narrator, Nathan Zuckerman, calls "the Devil of the Little Place--the
gossip, the jealousy, the acrimony, the boredom, the lies."
But shocking, intensely dramatized events
precipitate Silk's crisis. He remarks of two students who never showed up
for class, "Do they exist or are they spooks?" They turn out to be black,
and lodge a bogus charge of racism exploited by his enemies. Then, at 71,
Viagra catapults Silk into "the perpetual state of emergency that is sexual
intoxication," and he ignites an affair with an illiterate janitor, Faunia
Farley, 34. She's got a sharp sensibility, "the laugh of a barmaid who keeps
a baseball bat at her feet in case of trouble," and a melancholy
voluptuousness. "I'm back in the tornado," Silk exults. His campus
persecutors burn him for it--and his main betrayer is Delphine Roux.
In a short space, it's tough to convey the
gale-force quality of Silk's rants, or the odd effect of Zuckerman's
narration, alternately retrospective and torrentially in the moment. The
flashbacks to Silk's youth in New Jersey are just as important as his
turbulent forced retirement, because it turns out that for his entire adult
life, Silk has been covering up the fact that he is a black man. (If this
seems implausible, consider that the famous New York Times book
critic Anatole Broyard did the same thing.) Young Silk rejects both the
racism that bars him from Woolworth's counter and the Negro solidarity of
Howard University. "Neither the they of Woolworth's nor the we of Howard" is
for Coleman Silk. "Instead the raw I with all its agility. Self-discovery--that
was the punch to the labonz.... Self-knowledge but concealed. What is
as powerful as that?"
Silk's contradictions power a great Philip Roth
novel, but he's not the only character who packs a punch. Faunia, brutally
abused by her Vietnam vet husband (a sketchy guy who seems to have wandered
in from a lesser Russell Banks novel), scarred by the death of her kids, is
one of Roth's best female characters ever. The self-serving Delphine Roux is
intriguingly (and convincingly) nutty, and any number of minor characters
pop in, mouth off, kick ass, and vanish, leaving a vivid sense of human
passion and perversity behind. You might call it a stain. --Tim Appelo
From Publishers Weekly
Roth almost never fails to
surprise. After a clunky beginning, in which crusty Nathan Zuckerman is
carrying on about the orgy of sanctimoniousness surrounding Clinton's Monica
misadventures, his new novel settles into what would seem to be patented
Roth territory. Coleman Silk, at 71 a distinguished professor at a small New
England college, has been harried from his position because of what has been
perceived as a racist slur. His life is ruined: his wife succumbs under the
strain, his friends are forsaking him, and he is reduced to an affair with
34-year-old Faunia Farley, the somber and illiterate janitor at the college.
It is at this point that Zuckerman, Roth's novelist alter ego, gets to know
and like Silk and to begin to see something of the personal and sexual
liberation wrought in him by the unlikely affair with Faunia. It is also the
point at which Faunia's estranged husband Les Farley, a Vietnam vet disabled
by stress, drugs and drink, begins to take an interest in the relationship.
So far this is highly intelligent, literate entertainment, with a rising
tension. Will Les do something violent? Will Delphine Roux, the young French
professor Silk had hired, who has come to hate him, escalate the college's
campaign against him? Yes, but she now wants to make something of his Faunia
relationship too. Then, in a dazzling coup, Roth turns all expectations on
their heads, and begins to show Silk in a new and astounding light, as
someone who has lived a huge lie all his life, making the fuss over his
alleged racism even more surreal. The book continues to unfold layer after
layer of meaning. There is a tragedy, as foretold, and an exquisitely
imagined ending in which Zuckerman himself comes to feel both threatened and
a threat. Roth is working here at the peak of his imaginative skills,
creating many scenes at once sharply observed and moving: Faunia's affinity
for the self-contained remoteness of crows, Farley's profane longing for a
cessation to the tumult in his head, Zuckerman delightedly dancing with Silk
to the big band tunes of their youth. He even brings off virtuoso passages
that are superfluous but highly impressive, like his dissection of the
French professor's lonely anguish in the States. This is a fitting capstone
to the trilogy that includes American Pastoral and I Married a Communist--a
book more balanced and humane than either, and bound, because of its
explosive theme, to be widely discussed. 100,000 first printing.
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Beliefnet
It is a superb book, but not
for the reasons Roth wants it to be. He sells it as a political parable. The
title's human stain, and the exposition of the first five pages, remind us
that the book's action takes place in Impeachment Summer, 1998. Not just on
Monica's dress, the stain is on us all, original sin, a fact that should
make us more empathic, not less. Yet that summer, America's "piety binge ...
revived America's oldest communal passion, historically perhaps its most
treacherous and subversive pleasure: the ecstasy of sanctimony."
Roth's narrative is unsparing in its defense of
the private sphere and is a worthy reminder that private lives are best left
that way; his repudiation of self-righteousness as a mode of public carriage
should leave us all a little ashamed of much that we have done, or at least
suborned.
The salient tragedy of "The Human Stain" is not
Coleman Silk's imprisonment in the stocks of public opinion, a fate that
would not have befallen him had he never rejected his mother, siblings, and
race. (Of course, had he remained a black man after mid-century, would he
have become a tenured classicist at a baby-ivy college? A fair question.)
Rather, the import of "The Human Stain" lies in its humane, beautiful
dissection of a man who decides that freedom from race is worth total
estrangement from a loving family and a literate, educated, upwardly mobile
heritage that most Americans of all races would be happy to crow about. (Beliefnet,
May 2000)
The New York Times Book
Review, Lorrie Moore
The Human Stain is an
astonishing, uneven and often very beautiful book. edition.
From AudioFile
This novel completes the
trilogy begun in 1997 with AMERICAN PASTORAL and followed in 1998 with I
MARRIED A COMMUNIST. Here, Nathan Zuckerman, Roth's alter ego, tells the
story of Coleman Silk, an eminent classics professor forced to resign from
his New England college under charges of racism. The truth turns out to be
far more complex than the false accusation. Arliss Howard is the voice of
Zuckerman. He expertly conveys Zuckerman's varied emotions (outrage,
puzzlement, warmth) as he tries to learn the truth. The two sections of the
novel where the story is told by women are read by Debra Winger, and the
substitution is very effective. Both readers get high marks for keeping the
listener's rapt attention from start to finish. R.E.K. © AudioFile 2000,
Portland, Maine-- Copyright © AudioFile, Portland, Maine
From Booklist
With the help of his alter ego,
Nathan Zuckerman, Roth continues the inquiry into the state of the American
soul during the second half of the twentieth-century. Fueled by the story of
his magnetic hero, Coleman Silk, it roars, with heart-revving velocity,
through a literary landscape that embraces the politics of race and sex, the
Vietnam War, and the absurdity of extreme political correctness, the dumbing
down of the academy, and President Clinton's impeachment. Coleman, a
classics professor at a small Berkshire college, embodies all the ambition,
paradox, anger, and futility of the American dream, and, over the course of
his secretive life, he displays all the mettlesome powers of the Greek and
Roman gods he helps immortalize. Naturally, a man this fired up makes
enemies, and no one defends him when his brilliant career capsizes over a
misunderstanding regarding his use of the word spooks to refer to
students who failed to materialize in the classroom. How was he to know they
were black? How was anyone to know that he would be the last professor on
earth to make a racist remark? Enraged by the inanity of the ensuing
brouhaha, Coleman resigns. Then, when his wife dies unexpectedly, he becomes
involved with a woman who is half his age and illiterate. These unlikely
lovers are surely doomed, and Zuckerman seems destined to discover the truth
about Coleman, which reveals so many truths about the land he so
passionately portrays. As Roth unfurls his hero's galvanizing tale, he
protests the tyranny of prejudice and propriety, recognizes the
"terrifyingly provisional nature of everything," and shakes his head in
sorrow and wonder over the "inevitably stained creatures that we are."
Donna Seaman .
From Kirkus Reviews
Roth's extraordinary recent
productivity (the prizewinning Sabbath's Theater, 1995, and American
Pastoral, 1997) continues apace with this impressively replete and very
moving chronicle of an academic scandal and its impact on both the aging
professor at its center and his friend alter ego novelist Nathan Zuckerman.
In the turbulent summer of 1998 (while the country reacts with prurient
dismay to the Bill Clinton Monica Lewinsky mess), Coleman Silk, classics
teacher and Dean of Faculty at New England's Athena College, innocently uses
the word ``spook'' (correctly, as it happens) in class, and is immediately
accused of racism. His career and reputation are in ruins, his wife dies as
a result of the ensuing emotional trauma, and Silk becomes estranged from
his several adult children. Then, his ``exploitative'' ongoing affair with
Faunia Farley, a passive cleaning woman less than half his age, is
discovered. Zuckerman, in whom Coleman has confided, befriends him, hears
him out then, following the last of the story's several climaxes, sedulously
``reconstructs'' his beleaguered friend's history (``I am forced to imagine.
It happens to be what I do for a living''). There's another secret in
Coleman's past and Zuckerman/Roth teases it out and explores its
consequences in a back-and-forth narrative filled with surprises that
strains plausibility severely, while simultaneously involving us deeply with
its vividly imagined characters. In addition to Coleman Silk (whose
arrogance and secretiveness in no way lessen our respect for him), Roth
creates telling and unusually full characterizations of the semiliterate
Faunia (both a pathetic victim of circumstance and a formidably strong
woman); her angry ex-husband Les, a Vietnam vet crippled by post-traumatic
stress disorder; and even Delphine Roux, Coleman's single-minded feminist
colleague, and his most dedicated enemy. And in the long elegiac final
scene, Zuckerman contrives a resolution that may confer forgiveness on them
all. A marvel of imaginative empathy, generosity, and tact. Roth's late
maturity looks more and more like his golden age.-- Copyright © 2000
Kirkus Associates, LP. All rights reserved.
The New York Times
Mr. Roth does a beautifully
nuanced job...by turns, unnerving, hilarious and sad.
The Chicago Tribune
With THE HUMAN STAIN, Philip
Roth, the great autobiographer, has transformed himself into Philip Roth,
the great social novelist.
Christian Science Monitor
"The Human Stain" provides one
of the most provocative explorations of race and rage in American
literature.
Christian Science Monitor
"The Human Stain" provides one
of the most provocative explorations of race and rage in American
literature.
The Miami Herald
"... this novel...eloquently
makes its case for the transcendent complexity of the human soul."
Newsday
"To be human, Roth tells us in
this roiling, sometimes persuasive novel, is to make our dirty mark."
Time Magazine
"At 67, Roth has not lost one
ampere of his power to rile and surprise.
Time Magazine
"At 67, Roth has not lost one
ampere of his power to rile and surprise."
Review
"A marvel of imaginative
empathy, generosity, and tact. Roth's late maturity looks more and more like
his golden age."
Book Description
It is 1998, the year in which
America is whipped into a frenzy of prurience by the impeachment of a
president, and in a small New England town, an aging classics professor,
Coleman Silk, is forced to retire when his colleagues decree that he is a
racist. The charge is a lie, but the real truth about Silk would have
astonished even his most virulent accuser.
Coleman Silk has a secret, one which has been kept for
fifty years from his wife, his four children, his colleagues, and his
friends, including the writer Nathan Zuckerman. It is Zuckerman who stumbles
upon Silk's secret and sets out to reconstruct the unknown biography of this
eminent, upright man, esteemed as an educator for nearly all his life, and
to understand how this ingeniously contrived life came unraveled. And to
understand also how Silk's astonishing private history is, in the words of
The Wall Street Journal, "magnificently" interwoven with "the
larger public history of modern America."
From the Back Cover
"In American literature today,
there's Philip Roth, and then there's everybody else." —Chicago Tribune
“By turns unnerving, hilarious, and sad…. It is a book
that shows how the public zeitgeist can shape, even destroy, an individual’s
life…. Not only a philosophic bookend to American Pastoral but a
large and stirring book as well.”–Michiko Kakutani, The New York Times
"Philip Roth's The Human Stain is the best novel
he has written—not to devalue the past. Here, everything the writer has
learnt and experienced within that indefinable form we call the novel, the
impact of society on himself and the people around him, world contemporary
mores, beliefs, prejudices, have come to full realization." —Nadine Gordimer,
The Times Literary Supplement (International Book of the Year
Selection)
"A master novelist's haunting parable about our
troubled modern moment." —Sam Tanenhaus, The Wall Street Journal
About the Author
Philip Roth received the 1960
National Book Award in fiction for Goodbye, Columbus. He has twice
received the National Book Critics Circle Award—in 1987 for the novel The
Counterlife and in 1992 for Patrimony. Operation Shylock
won the PEN/Faulkner Award for Fiction and was chosen by Time
magazine as the best American novel of 1993. In 1995, Roth's Sabbaths
Theater received the National Book Award in fiction. In 1998, he
received the Pulitzer Prize for American Pastoral and was a White
House recipient of the National Medal of Arts. His other books include the
trilogy and epilogue Zuckerman Bound; the novels Letting Go, My
life as a Man, and The Professor of Desire; and the political
satire Our Gang.
|